Read reviews Add a review
3.75
Average: 3.8 (4 votes)

Mar_D's picture
Written on Thursday, August 29, 2019
by
3

Hello girls!

 

In this review, I want to share my thoughts on this eyeliner.

It’s a cream eyeliner in a jar from E.L.F.

 

It was a spontaneous purchase for me. I was hooked with a beautiful elegant jar, good price and tons of positive reviews.

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

Currently, it’s been 3 months since I bought it.

 

During the first month of use, I ALREADY changed my opinion about it. At first, I loved it but then it changed with a desire to throw it away. I’ll tell you why.

 

ABOUT THE PRODUCT:

 

Price: $3-4

Weight: 4.7g

Made in China, even though the brand is American.

 

It comes in two shades: black and brown. I bought the classy black one for me.

 

The packaging has suffered a little while transporting but I don’t care.

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

The pack also includes a featured brush.

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

The design of the jar is so cute. You won’t even tell it’s affordable. It’s very pleasant to use. Wink

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

 

The color seems charcoal black in the tube. Also, there’s a lot of it.

It’s noteworthy the shelf life of the product is 3 months! How ever one can use such a jar up within 3 months? Smile

 

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

 

The formula is unscented.

 

🌿 INGREDIENTS

Isododecane, cyclopentasiloxane, polyethylene, trimethylsiloxysilicate, microcrystalline wax (cera microcristallina), ozokerite, polyglyceryl-2 isostearate/dimer dilinoleate copolymer, phenoxyethanol, tocopheryl acetate (ve).

May Contain: Mice (cl 77019), titanium dioxide (cl 77891), iron oxide (cl 77491, cl 77492, cl 77499), ultramarines (cl 77007), chromium oxide greens (cl 77288).

 

🌿 MY THOUGHTS ABOUT IT

 

A few words about me: you see, my eyes are hooded. They almost cover the eyeliner edge. Yet, I still draw lines to deepen my eyes and visually fan my lashes.

BUT, staying power is essential for me. Also, I appreciate how quickly the product sets. Everything that doesn’t set within 30 seconds will eventually stain my eyes. And I don’t want that.

 

At first, I was head over heels with this eyeliner! Starting with the aesthetic delight from use because of that beautiful packaging and finishing with the black and saturated color and its wear time.

 

So, let’s move onto makeup.

 

The featured brush is bullshit for me. It’s too thick and short. Since the product sets quickly, I don’t have any time to tame the brush.

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

 

I bought another one for this product.

 

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

In the beginning, the lines from the product were precise and thick. No patches but matte finish. The color wasn’t charcoal black but it was still worthy.

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

It used to set quicky and never budge or stain my upper lids. A dream for hooded eyes isn’t it!

 

However, that thick and creamy texture was impossible to give the thinnest lines. And I started to draw them thicker.

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

In a word, the product was good at first.

 

But, less than in a month, it started to dry down and the color turned into more like gray rather than black. Besides, it started to leave a patchy finish behind.

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

This is what it looked like on my eyes. The line isn’t smooth and the tips are pathetic because of the texture.

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

You won’t detect it when my eyes are open (because they are hooded) but I’m still very disappointed about its quality.

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner
E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

And now, about its performance during the day.

I can’t be picky here:

 

  • it doesn’t smudge or stain my upper lids

  • it doesn’t fade in color (it remains the same during the day)

  • it doesn’t flake off

  • it doesn’t irritate my eyes

  • it doesn’t budge and sets quickly

  • it removes with micellar water or cleansing oil. Just water won’t do anything with it.

 

🌿OVERALL

 

I’ll sum up.

 

The good:

  • affordable price tag

  • beautiful packaging

  • saturated color

  • it doesn’t budge or stain my lids

 

The bad:

  • it dries down quickly in the jar

  • the featured brush is useless. You’ll have to find a good brush for it. It also requires some skills.

Although the price is affordable, I still won’t repurchase.

There are much easier products to use in the market. Any affordable eyeliner will do the job better and live a longer life, while lines will be more precise, and blacker.

 

Never recommended

report to moderator

Mar_D doesn't recommend E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner

How helpful is this review?
Group Copy 7
Remove the review The review contains spam, advertisement or Site rules violations. The review has to be removed.
Not helpful The review is not helpful. It must be corrected.
Somewhat Helpful The review is helpful, but additions/improvements are advised.
Helpful The review is good, it contains a lot of helpful information.
Great The review is very helpful, it contains a lot of information about the product, styled text, high-quality photos.
Type: Eyeliner
Brand: E.L.F.
Category: Make-Up
Other reviews
See also