Read reviews Add a review
Average: 4 (2 votes)

Annitr's picture
Written on Friday, September 28, 2018

Hello beautiful ladies! Smile

I carry on looking through my lip glosses and lipsticks collection and showing them to you. When it comes to a lip product for me, I have to say that I’m rather constant here. Usually, I opt for some nude lipsticks and my favorite formula is a lip gloss or creamy moisturizing lipstick.

Today we have the Tarte Amazonian Butter Lipstick to review, which I do love, though I can’t recommend it to you, unfortunately.

The design is exciting and cute! So nice, feminine and spring-like. The casing is cardboard, it’s of rather good quality, so I have nothing negative to say about it. Each shade from the collection has its own unique printing, so if you have some of them, it won’t be a problem to distinguish them.

Size - 3.1g.

Manufacturing country - the USA.

Expires within 12 months of opening.

The lippie has the gentlest, softest and really butter-like texture. And due to that gentle texture, the product shows its first disadvantage. You see, it’s so easy to break down, especially in summer when it melts down. And it’s just a catastrophe! It’s impossible to take up with me, ever. So there isn’t any chance to touch-up. The stick will fall out and break down for sure. One more thing is that the stick always touches the rims of the casing. To top it off I have to confess that my lipstick broke down after the first use.

All summer my Tarte Amazonian Butter Lipstick was chilling out in my fridge. And it feels good only there. Maybe I’ll take it out in winter but still, I guess it won’t go longer than my fridge anyway.

The coverage from this lipstick is semi-sheer with a glossy shiny finish. It’s really comfortable and nourishing for my lip. It even looks more like a lip gloss, rather than a lipstick. But once I start applying this gentle texture on my lips, I always face one more problem. The coverage that it gives never looks smooth.

The product settles down in my fine lip lines, it accentuates all the flaky bits and if your lips have relief, it’s very likely that it’ll feather. However, it still never gathers with a white film on my inner lip. Good! I still can apply it evenly but it requires so much effort. Perfect lips, this is the only thing that it requires to look good.(mine aren’t bad indeed) I always have to let it for about 5-10 minutes after application to smooth out and set on my lips. Only after that, I can leave my house.

The staying power is average, so to speak - 2-3 hours maybe.

It fades delicately and evenly. There isn’t any distinctive flavor or smell to the formula, though the mint note is still remarkable. But it doesn’t tingle my skin or cool it down.

The Amazonian Butter Lipstick collection doesn’t offer a wide range of colors to select, as all of them look versatile and semi-sheer.

For me, I chose the shade called Golden Pink, which is gentle and pinky peach.

I was going to buy the entire collection, but facing all that mumbo-jumbo with this one, I quickly changed my mind. It isn’t worth all that, even though I still passionately love it for unknown reasons.

This Tarte Amazonian Butter Lipstick has some serious drawbacks and it’s way worse than many other lipsticks quality-wise. But, it’s so loved and cherished by me that I still forgive it a lot and store in my already stuffed fridge. I can’t and won’t recommend it for purchasing. It’ll be much easier to find a dupe for this lipstick. As for me, I’ll keep on using it with great pleasure.

Price - $17

Thanks for your attention to my post and have a pleasant shopping day! Wink

report to moderator

Annitr doesn't recommend Tarte Amazonian Butter Lipstick

How helpful is this review?
Group Copy 7
Remove the review The review contains spam, advertisement or Site rules violations. The review has to be removed.
Not helpful The review is not helpful. It must be corrected.
Somewhat Helpful The review is helpful, but additions/improvements are advised.
Helpful The review is good, it contains a lot of helpful information.
Great The review is very helpful, it contains a lot of information about the product, styled text, high-quality photos.
Type: Lipstick
Brand: Tarte
Category: Make-Up
Other reviews
  • Butter miracle for my lips…

    Nuririna's picture

    This lipstick got onto my wishlist after I watched its promo on the official site of the brand. But for a long time, I couldn’t dare to order it. Because there was a problem - how to choose the right shade for me?