Read reviews Add a review
Average: 3.7 (3 votes)

Irenesmall's picture
Written on Tuesday, October 24, 2017

Hello gals!

Today I’m back to review the Make Up For Ever Professional Aqua Liner in the shade #3.

The outer appearance of the product is very beautiful, stylish and posh. The applicator is long and black while the bottom of the tube is the same color as the liner.

The tube is thin and very convenient to hold in hand.

As for the content, here everything’s also good. Consistency-wise the product isn’t too thick or runny. Just ideal for a liquid liner. And here I’d like to say about the first disadvantage I found: the pigmentation isn’t good. (I speak only about my tube and my shade, maybe the pigmentation is stunning in other shades).

Sheer coverage is something out of this world for a product that costs so much. And it costs $23 by the way. Pardon, but I’ll be able to find a way better product for less money. I know that the brand is professional and popular and we have to pay for it. But they also have to release good quality products in return then, don’t they?

The first layer applies with some clumps and looks very sheer. Well thank God the second layer applies better evening out the discoloration. As for the staying power: they say that the product is waterproof. Well, I don’t agree. If you get caught in rain, the liner will still stay on your eyes, that’s true. But if you touch your eye, the product will instantly become smudged. And here’s a pro that the product will not make you looking like a panda.

The product comes off with a film and I usually remove with micellar water. No rubbing my eyes is required.

I liked the applicator and its foam tip.

It may seem to be too thick but that’s not true. The tip is very thin and you’ll easily draw the line of your liking.

One more thing that I noticed while applying this eyeliner is that it makes my eyelashes clumpy, I mean if I accidentally touch my eyelashes with this eyeliner, they’ll immediately become stuck together and clumpy and I’ll have to do something with them before applying mascara.

In a few words these are the pros and cons of the product:


  • wide range of colors

  • beautiful packaging

  • doesn’t get smudged while wearing

  • easy to remove with micellar water

  • good applicator

  • isn’t imprinted on my upper lids


  • Price. For the money you can buy some cream eyeshadow that will be both - eyeliner and eyeshadow as well.

  • bad pigmented color

  • the first layer looks too sheer

  • not actually waterproof

In a nutshell, I won’t recommend buying this eyeliner, as a cheaper product may perform better.

Thanks for spending these minutes with me. See you!...

report to moderator

Irenesmall doesn't recommend Make Up For Ever Aqua Liner Liquid Eyeliner

How helpful is this review?
Group Copy 7
Remove the review The review contains spam, advertisement or Site rules violations. The review has to be removed.
Not helpful The review is not helpful. It must be corrected.
Somewhat Helpful The review is helpful, but additions/improvements are advised.
Helpful The review is good, it contains a lot of helpful information.
Great The review is very helpful, it contains a lot of information about the product, styled text, high-quality photos.
Category: Make-Up
Other reviews
See also